Accueil International China, India blame each other for border clash as death toll remains...

China, India blame each other for border clash as death toll remains unknown

India has accused China of trying to change the « status quo » by making « exaggerated and untenable » claims of sovereignty over the disputed Galwan Valley, after soldiers from both nations were involved in a deadly brawl in the hotly contested region this week.

Key points:

China hasn’t revealed its number of deaths but claims India provoked the attackIndian PM Modi said the death of Indian troops « would not be in vain » The two nuclear-armed Asian giants have agreed to dialogue to resolve tensions

India has reported 20 Indian soldiers, including a colonel, have died of severe injuries in the dispute on Monday night local time.

Indian news outlet ANI cited unnamed sources saying at least 43 Chinese troops were dead or seriously injured.

Chinese officials and media have admitted to casualties but so far remained silent on the number of deaths.

When questioned regarding the number of Chinese casualties, Foreign Ministry spokesperson Zhao Lijian said: « The border troops of the two sides are dealing with the specifics on the ground. »

Hu Xijin, editor of the nationalistic Chinese-state owned Global Times, said in a Weibo post the Chinese side had sustained casualties.

« According to the information I got from the people who are familiar with the matter at my urgent request, our side also suffered casualties, » he wrote, without providing further detail.

China and India accused each other of instigating the conflict.

India and China’s border dispute

Narendra Modi and Xi JinpingNarendra Modi and Xi Jinping

Why are troops from two nuclear-armed countries clashing with sticks and stones, and how did this decades-long dispute begin?

Read more

China said Indian forces carried out « provocative attacks » on its troops.

« Shockingly, on June 15, the Indian troops … crossed the LAC [Line of Actual Control] for illegal activities, and provoked and attacked Chinese personnel, which caused violent physical clashes between the two sides, causing casualties, » Mr Zhao said.

India, however, levelled the blame on « an attempt by the Chinese side to unilaterally change the status quo there », with Indian media reports saying Indian officials tried to dismantle a tent on the Line of Actual Control that overlooked Indian positions.

« Both sides have agreed that the overall situation should be handled in a responsible manner, » a statement from India’s Ministry of External Affairs said.

« Making exaggerated and untenable claims is contrary to this understanding. »

Loading

Former Indian army Colonel Ajai Shukla referred to the « aggressiveness that the Chinese have displayed on the ground ».

« The killing of 20 people, Indian soldiers, on Monday night is just one dimension of it. But the other dimension is how they were killed. They were thrown off cliffs, they were bludgeoned to death, » he told the ABC.

« It was completely savage. »

The former Colonel has been highly critical of the Modi Government’s handling of the conflict, saying it has tried and failed to use appeasement.

« The Government is now probably waking up to the seriousness and gravity of the situation, » he said.

Long-simmering tensions

Indian officials said soldiers were hit with rocks and clubs studded with nails during the brawl that erupted in the remote Galwan Valley, high in the mountains where India’s Ladakh region borders the Aksai Chinese region captured by China during the 1962 war.

Under an old agreement between the two nuclear-armed Asian giants, no shots are to be fired at the border, where both countries claim vast swathes of each other’s territory along the Himalayan border.

A night-time brawl broke out and lasted hours, according to local media reports, while some soldiers lost their footing and plunged to their deaths in the steep mountain terrain.

Kashmiri Bakarwal nomads walk with a donkey and children as an Indian army convoy drives past.Kashmiri Bakarwal nomads walk with a donkey and children as an Indian army convoy drives past. China says it is seeking a peaceful resolution to its Himalayan border dispute with India after their most violent confrontation in decades.(AP: Mukhtar Khan)

Nathan Ruser, a researcher at the Australian Strategic Policy Institute, said satellite imagery showed brewing tensions.

« We’ve seen both sides set up military positions a lot closer to the demarcation line, and a lot closer to each other, » he told the ABC.

« In the Galwan Valley, previously the forces were multiple kilometres apart. Now they’re within a few hundred metres of each other, at least prior to the recent engagement.

« In the Galwan Valley, a lot of the Chinese advances have been into a valley that allows them to set up positions into a ridgeline that looks over Indian positions. »

An annotated satellite image showing the Indian and Chinese army positions  in the Galwan Valley.An annotated satellite image showing the Indian and Chinese army positions  in the Galwan Valley. ASPI researcher Nathan Ruser said satellite images showed the Chinese and Indian militaries had moved much closer to each other.(Supplied: Nathan Ruser, ASPI)

Prime Minister Narendra Modi said in a speech Wednesday that: « India wants peace but is capable of giving a befitting reply. »

He has called a meeting of India’s major political parties on Friday to discuss the China situation.

Chinese State Councillor and Foreign Minister Wang Yi held phone talks with Indian Minister of External Affairs Subrahmanyam Jaishankar on Wednesday, urging the Indian side to thoroughly investigate the clash on the border of the two countries, the Chinese Foreign Ministry reported.

« China and India have agreed to keep on the track of dialogue and consultation to resolve the relevant issue and work to alleviate the situation on the ground, » Mr Zhao said.

In response to a query on the statement by the Chinese side that the sovereignty of the Galwan Valley area belongs to China, the official spokesperson Anurag Srivastava reiterated the two sides had a phone conversation about the recent developments in Ladakh.

An editorial in the nationalistic state-owned Global Times, a Chinese Government mouthpiece, said: « We believe Indian society should wake up from its geopolitical fantasy » and « view China pragmatically ».

« The Indian side should never think about pushing China to make concessions, because China won’t. Moreover, China’s countermeasures will never be late no matter the cost. »

Funerals for Indian soldiers underway

Indian army soldiers dressed in military uniform carry the coffin of their colleague.Indian army soldiers dressed in military uniform carry the coffin of their colleague. Indian army soldiers carry the coffin of their colleague Sunil Kumar, who was killed during the confrontation.(AP: Aftab Alam Siddiqui)

As funerals for the 20 soldiers killed in the brawl commenced, protesters gathered outside the Chinese embassy in New Delhi and in other cities across India, with many burning photos of Chinese President Xi Jinping.

« We have assembled here to pay our respects, the way they gave their lives fighting bravely, » said Ashok Goel from among the crowds.

« Today all of the country is standing with them, with their families. »

Indians light candles in front of pictures of men that were killed.Indians light candles in front of pictures of men that were killed. Mourners light candles in Hyderabad to pay tributes to Indian soldiers killed during the clash.(AP: Mahesh Kumar A)

Prime Minister Narendra Modi led a two-minute silence for the Indian soldiers who lost their lives and said India would « defend every stone, every inch of its territory ».

« I would like to assure the nation that the sacrifice of our jawans [troops] will not be in vain, » he said, speaking at a televised meeting of India’s chief ministers.

« For us, the unity and sovereignty of the country is the most important. »

A further escalation should not be ruled out, said Pravin Sawhney, a military expert and editor of FORCE, a monthly magazine focused on national security.

« They [China] are fully prepared for it, » he said.

« On the other hand, India’s response has been very subdued and defensive in nature. There is no immediate threat of an all-out war with China but India should be concerned about an exit strategy and I fear they have none. »

  • Ansmann BatteryBox 9V
    Ansmann BatteryBox 9V, storage box for up to 9V batteries, can be expanded as required by a special connection system - simply plug the boxes into each other